Can a cheque be recalled if the bank subsequently discovered that the customer’s account was overdrawn?

Saskatchewan, Canada


The following excerpt is from Bank of Montreal v. Heidt, 1972 CanLII 744 (SK QB):

An often-cited case, Chambers v. Miller et al. (1862), 13 C.B.N.S. 125, 143 E.R. 50, dealing with the effect of the presentation of the cheque and its payment, held that upon payment the property in the notes and money passed from the bankers to the bearer of the cheque and could not be revoked. In this case, Byles J. at p. 52 stated in the course of argument: “I do not remember any case where it has been held that the payment of a cheque can be recalled by reason of the banker subsequently discovering that the customer’s account was overdrawn.” and Erle C.J. stated at p. 53 as follows: “With regard to cheques, the well-known course of business is this, — When a cheque is presented at the counter of a banker, the banker has authority on the part of his customer to pay the amount therein specified on his account. The money in the banker’s hands is his own money. On presentment of the cheque, it is for the banker to consider whether the state of the account between him and his customer will justify him in passing the property in the money to the holder of the cheque . . . But, according to the intention of the parties, and the course of business, the money had ceased to be the money of the bankers, and had become that of the party presenting the cheque . . . The bankers’ clerk chose to pay the cheque; and the moment the person presenting the cheque put his hand upon the money it became irrevocably his.”

Other Questions


When a broker has mixed shares of his own and shares bought for customers in a common block of shares, does the customer have an equitable right to the number bought on his account? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
Does a subsequent purchaser of the legal estate have to pay the full consideration of the purchase, even after the purchase was completed, if the subsequent purchaser has paid the entire amount of consideration, even though the previous purchaser had a prior equitable interest in the property? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
In what circumstances will the bank of a parish be required to return a cheque drawn on account of the parish? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
Is a lawyer’s trust account held by the bankrupt divisible among his creditors? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
Is evidence of a subsequent declaration of intent admissible to enhance damages? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
Is a cheque marked “in full of claim” valid? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
When a vendor contracts to sell to a purchaser an agreement for a lease and the purchaser subsequently repudiates the contract, can the vendor continue to exercise its right to exercise that right? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
In what circumstances have accounts been admitted without objection? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
Is a Chartered Accountant's Charter of Charter Freedoms a violation or limitation on freedom of expression by the Respondent's Charter or its bylaws? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What is the obligation of a person who is discovered during a medical examination to inform himself on all matters material to the issues? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
X



Alexi white


"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.