What is the test for novation in a mortgage?

Ontario, Canada


The following excerpt is from Standard Trust Company v. Metropolitan Trust Company of Canada, 2006 CanLII 589 (ON SC):

In Mead at p. 427 Wilson J. outlines the requirements for a novation: A novation is a trilateral agreement by which an existing contract is extinguished and a new contract brought into being in its place. Indeed, for an agreement to effect a valid novation the appropriate consideration is the discharge of the original debt in return for a promise to perform some obligation. The assent of the beneficiary (the creditor or mortgagee) of those obligations to the discharge and substitution is crucial. This is because the effect of novation is that the creditor may no longer look to the original party if the obligations under the substituted contract are not subsequently met as promised. Because assent is the crux of novation it is obvious that novation may not be forced upon an unwilling creditor and, in the absence of express agreement, the court should be loath to find novation unless the circumstances are really compelling. Thus, while the court may look at the surrounding circumstances, including the conduct of the parties, in order to determine whether a novation has occurred, the burden of establishing novation is not easily met. The courts have established a three-part test for determining if novation has occurred. It is set out in Polson v. Wulffsohn (1890), 2 B.C.R. 39 as follows: 1. The new debtor must assume the complete liability; 2. The creditor must accept the new debtor as principal debtor and not merely as an agent or guarantor; and 3. The creditor must accept the new contract in full satisfaction and substitution for the old contract. and at p. 430: In my view, significant changes in the terms of a mortgage effected without the consent of the original mortgagor constitute very strong evidence of novation. It is not necessary, of course, for a different contract to be brought into existence for a novation to take place. The essence of novation is the substitution of debtors. However, where significant changes in terms occur and the creditor has not applied to the original mortgagor for its consent, I believe this is a strong indication that the creditor is no longer looking to the mortgagor for payment.

Other Questions


Does a mortgage with attornation clause in the mortgage law apply to a mortgage where the mortgage is not attornment clause? (Ontario, Canada)
What is the test for a mortgage lender's ability to assess the value of a mortgage security under mortgage law? (Ontario, Canada)
Does the mere possession of a mortgage deed by a solicitor or conveyancer prove authority to receive mortgage money? (Ontario, Canada)
What is the test for a revocation of a mortgage where a licensee has knowingly participated in mortgage fraud? (Ontario, Canada)
What are the costs of a CIBC MORTGAGES Inc. trading as FIRSTLINE Mortgages? (Ontario, Canada)
If a mortgage is renewed, does the original mortgage set out the principal amount and the interest rate calculated half-yearly not in advance? (Ontario, Canada)
In what circumstances will a mortgage company be found to have made a mistake in upholding the mortgage? (Ontario, Canada)
What is required to complete a mortgage advance under TD Waterhouse's Arm's Length Mortgage Agreement? (Ontario, Canada)
What is a 25% discount when a mortgage is advanced to pay off a couple's mortgage? (Ontario, Canada)
What is the effect of consolidating two mortgages into a single large mortgage registered on March 4, 2013? (Ontario, Canada)
X



Alexi white


"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.