If a garnishee summons is served after crystallization of the security provided by the debenture, which should have priority?

Alberta, Canada


The following excerpt is from Alberta Paper Company Ltd. v. Metropolitan Graphics Ltd., 1983 CanLII 1114 (AB QB):

However, I need not consider this point further because in the present case the garnishee summons was served after crystallization of the security provided by the debenture. Where service of the garnishee summons follows crystallization, the debenture would in all cases have priority. Crystallization, having created a legal interest in the debenture holder, protects him from all subsequent claims, be they equitable, legal or otherwise. The rule in Dearle v. Hall would be inapplicable as the competition would involve at least one legal interest. In order to succeed, the applicant would have had to prove that service of the garnishee summons preceded crystallization. Moreover, if I am wrong in the view I have inconclusively expressed, that a floating charge creates no interest prior to crystallization, then the applicant would also have to convince the court that service of the summons created an equitable interest in the garnished funds.

Other Questions


Does an employee have priority over a floating charge debenture holder where a receiver is appointed? (Alberta, Canada)
What is the test for reasonable accommodation provided by a service provider to an employee who suffers from multiple sclerosis? (Alberta, Canada)
Can a garnishee order be made at source? (Alberta, Canada)
Can an employee who has served as an employee of a bankrupt subsidiary of a corporation for more than a decade be held liable for breach of contract by that bankrupt subsidiary? (Alberta, Canada)
What is the test for self-serving statements in a criminal case? (Alberta, Canada)
What services provided by a professional accountant may not be within the broad scope of reviewing and reporting on financial information? (Alberta, Canada)
Can a garnishee be issued before judgment? (Alberta, Canada)
Can a garnishee be held liable for the full amount of a plaintiff’s claim? (Alberta, Canada)
Can Pembina be held vicariously liable for the actions of Secure? (Alberta, Canada)
Can a sentence of 6 years imprisonment be served consecutively? (Alberta, Canada)
X



Alexi white


"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.