Can a finding that highway regulation or safety concerns animated a traffic stop be set aside?

Ontario, Canada


The following excerpt is from R. v. Gonzales, 2017 ONCA 543 (CanLII):

A trial judge’s finding that highway regulation or safety concerns was a purpose that animated a traffic stop is a finding of fact. As a consequence, the finding is subject to deference and cannot be set aside by this court unless it is unreasonable or based upon a material misapprehension of the evidence adduced at trial: Brown v. Durham, at para. 27.

Sometimes, a traffic stop may have more than one purpose. However, the mere existence of another purpose motivating the stop, beyond highway regulation and safety concerns, does not render the stop unlawful. But the additional purpose must itself not be improper, or proper but pursued through improper means, and must not entail an infringement on the liberty or security of any detained person beyond that contemplated by the purpose that underpins s. 216(1): Brown v. Durham, at paras. 31, 34, 37-39 and 45.

Other Questions


When will the court make a finding of fact or finding of not finding fact in a personal injury case? (Ontario, Canada)
What are the elements of speeding under section 128 of the Highway Traffic Act? (Ontario, Canada)
What is the test for police to stop and videotape motorcyclists for traffic safety reasons? (Ontario, Canada)
Is a vehicle stopped by the police for highway traffic reasons or pursuant to s. 216(1) of the Criminal Code? (Ontario, Canada)
Does a finding that the moving party on a motion made without notice fully and fairly disclose all the material facts result in the order being set aside? (Ontario, Canada)
What is the legal test for overturning a finding of fact or finding of law? (Ontario, Canada)
Does the limitation period for damage caused by defective wiring in a car constitute a limitation period under the Highway Traffic Act? (Ontario, Canada)
Can an acquittal be set aside on the basis that the finding is not supported by the element? (Ontario, Canada)
Does a finding of fact made on an interlocutory finding in a separate judicial proceeding engage in issue estoppel in a subsequent proceeding? (Ontario, Canada)
Can an appellate court substitute a trial judge’s findings of fact or mixed findings of law with its own? (Ontario, Canada)
X



Alexi white


"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.