What is the test for a felony-murder special circumstance?

California, United States of America


The following excerpt is from People v. Nieves, 11 Cal.5th 404, 278 Cal.Rptr.3d 40, 485 P.3d 457 (Cal. 2021):

Defendant contends the evidence was insufficient to support the "independent felonious intent required for the arson-murder special circumstance." ( People v. Mendoza (2000) 24 Cal.4th 130, 183, 99 Cal.Rptr.2d 485, 6 P.3d 150 ( Mendoza ).) "The requirement

[485 P.3d 507]

of an independent felonious purpose applies to felony-murder special-circumstance findings under section 190.2, subdivision (a)(17). [Citation.] This subdivision authorizes a special circumstance finding when the murder was committed while the defendant was engaged in ... the commission of [or] the attempted commission of various other specified felonies. ( 190.2, subd. (a)(17).)" ( People v. Powell , supra , 5 Cal.5th at p. 953, 236 Cal.Rptr.3d 316, 422 P.3d 973.)

As we explained in Mendoza , "[a] felony-murder special circumstance, such as arson murder, may be alleged when the murder occurs during the commission of the felony, not when the felony occurs during the commission of a murder. [Citations.] Thus, to prove a felony-murder special-circumstance allegation, the prosecution must show that the defendant had an independent purpose for the commission of the felony, that is, the commission of the felony was not merely incidental to an intended murder." ( Mendoza , supra , 24 Cal.4th at p. 182, 99 Cal.Rptr.2d 485, 6 P.3d 150.) "Concurrent intent to kill and to commit an independent felony will support a felony-murder special circumstance." ( Id . at p. 183, 99 Cal.Rptr.2d 485, 6 P.3d 150 ; see also People v. Raley (1992) 2 Cal.4th 870, 903, 8 Cal.Rptr.2d 678, 830 P.2d 712.) We must therefore determine whether, viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to the prosecution, "any rational trier of fact could have concluded that defendant had a purpose for the arson apart from the murder." ( Mendoza , at p. 183, 99 Cal.Rptr.2d 485, 6 P.3d 150.)

Other Questions


Is there a "special circumstance" where a jury did not return a finding on the alleged special circumstance? (California, United States of America)
Does the amendment to the lying-in-wait special circumstance in a murder case in which there is a distinction between the special circumstance and lying in-wait first degree murder? (California, United States of America)
Does a jury have to find intent to kill to sustain a special circumstance allegation in an attempted robbery special circumstance? (California, United States of America)
In what circumstances will the Court uphold the murder verdict and special circumstance findings? (California, United States of America)
In what circumstances will the court overturn a torture-murder special-circumstance finding? (California, United States of America)
In what circumstances will a defendant be found guilty of a special circumstance charge under Section 187 of the Penal Code? (California, United States of America)
What is the difference between a defendant's special instruction in a first degree murder case and a special circumstance finding? (California, United States of America)
In what circumstances will a jury be able to determine whether a defendant is guilty of multiple murder on the special circumstance allegation? (California, United States of America)
How have the courts treated the defense's request for a special instruction against "double counting" the crimes and the special circumstances? (California, United States of America)
In what circumstances will a jury unanimously find a felony-murder special circumstance? (California, United States of America)
X



Alexi white


"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.