What is the legal test for a defendant to challenge his sentence under the Eighth Amendment of the United States?

California, United States of America


The following excerpt is from People v. Martinez, D062720 (Cal. App. 2014):

'considerable burden' to show the sentence is disproportionate to his level of culpability. [Citation.] Therefore, '[f]indings of disproportionality have occurred with exquisite rarity in the case law.' " (People v. Em (2009) 171 Cal.App.4th 964, 972.)

The Eighth Amendment, which applies to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution, prohibits cruel and unusual punishments. It "contains a 'narrow proportionality principle' that 'applies to noncapital sentences.' " (Ewing v. California (2003) 538 U.S. 11, 20.) The Eighth Amendment " 'does not require strict proportionality between crime and sentence. Rather, it forbids only extreme sentences that are "grossly disproportionate" to the crime.' " (Id. at p. 23.) As with claims under our state Constitution, in determining whether a sentence violates the federal constitutional guarantee against cruel and unusual punishment, a court may consider "the gravity of the offense and the harshness of the penalty." (Solem v. Helm (1983) 463 U.S. 277, 292.) "Outside the context of capital punishment, successful challenges to the proportionality of particular sentences [under the federal Constitution are] . . . exceedingly rare." (Rummell v. Estelle (1980) 445 U.S. 263, 272.)

Other Questions


What is the current state of the law on the Eighth Amendment, the "narrow proportionality principle" that applies to sentences for non-capital sentences? (California, United States of America)
What is the current state of the law on "cruel and unusual punishments" under the Eighth Amendment of the United States? (California, United States of America)
Does a joint capital sentencing proceeding violate the Eighth Amendment right to individualized sentencing determination? (California, United States of America)
Is a defendant entitled to a comparative sentence review equivalent to that provided for determinately sentenced felons under the "disparate sentence" statute? (California, United States of America)
Is a defendant's history of violence relevant to the sentencing of a defendant in a capital sentencing trial? (California, United States of America)
Is a defendant's sentence challenge based on Penal Code section 654 a challenge that affects the validity of his no contest pleas? (California, United States of America)
Can a defendant argue that the failure to dismiss jurors from a jury during the sentencing phase of a trial has violated his right to a reliable verdict under the Eighth Amendment? (California, United States of America)
What is the effect of section 190.3 of the Eighth Amendment on the sentencing of a defendant in a murder trial? (California, United States of America)
What is the case law on sentencing a defendant to a more severe sentence than a defendant convicted of murder? (California, United States of America)
What is the case law on sentencing a defendant to a more severe sentence than a defendant convicted of murder? (California, United States of America)
X



Alexi white


"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.