What is the law regarding the right of a party to be present during an out-of-court examination in a civil case?

Ontario, Canada


The following excerpt is from York University v. Markicevic, 2012 ONSC 5325 (CanLII):

The law regarding the right of a party to be present during an out-of-court examination in a civil case was described in detail in K.F. (Litigation guardian of) v. White[1] and Roe v. Leone.[2] Let me summarize the applicable principles: (i) There is an inherent right for parties to an action to be present during the cross-examination or examination for discovery of other parties to, or witnesses in, an action; (ii) The court has the discretion to exclude parties from attending such cross-examinations or examinations for discovery; (iii) However, the court does not establish classes of cases which eliminate a party’s inherent right to be present at an examination – “blanket exclusions” do not form part of our procedural law; (iv) The person seeking to exclude a party from an examination bears the onus, on a balance of probabilities, of showing cause to justify such an exclusion; (v) Cause depends on the circumstances of the case. Courts have defined cause as a realistic and substantial cause, circumstances that would cause prejudice to the party to be examined, or circumstances that make exclusion necessary to secure the ends of justice; and, (vi) Demonstrated intimidation by one party towards the other is a justifiable reason to exclude, however a court should guard against assuming intimidation from a set of circumstances. Intimidation must be proven.

Other Questions


Is there any case law or case law that states that parties are not aware of the effect of the case on the other side? (Ontario, Canada)
Does a party who brings the motion as well as the witnesses upon whom the moving/applying party relies have an obligation to present and present witnesses to the motion? (Ontario, Canada)
If a successful party accepts an offer to settle, can the successful party be ordered to pay all or part of the unsuccessful party’s costs? (Ontario, Canada)
What is the relevant case law for giving evidence from a third party witness in a personal injury case? (Ontario, Canada)
Can a motion judge strike a jury in a civil case because of the increased uncertainty in the Ottawa area due to the delay for any civil jury trial, in Ottawa? (Ontario, Canada)
Does a court order or an agreement regarding contribution to section 7 expenses in a child support case require a party to contribute to the expenses? (Ontario, Canada)
What is the obligation of a party moving for an order that will affect the rights of the absent party to make full and fair disclosure of all material facts? (Ontario, Canada)
Is a substantive right of trial by jury in a civil case? (Ontario, Canada)
Can a party who has been unsuccessful in a personal injury case rely on their own financial means, such as cash, to avoid the costs of the other party? (Ontario, Canada)
Does Age-Less have the right to conduct an examination of a judgment creditor of a party to a subsequent action commenced by the judgment creditor? (Ontario, Canada)
X



Alexi white


"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.