Is malice implied from the mere publication of defamatory material?

Saskatchewan, Canada


The following excerpt is from Cherneskey v. Armadale Publishers Limited, 1974 CanLII 963 (SK QB):

In Adam v. Ward, [1917] A.C. 309, Finlay L.C., at p. 318, said: “Malice is a necessary element in an action for libel, but from the mere publication of defamatory matter malice is implied, unless the publication was on what is called a privileged occasion. If the communication was made in pursuance of a duty or on a matter in which there was a common interest on the party making and the party receiving it, the occasion is said to be privileged. This privilege is only qualified and may be rebutted by proof of express malice. It is for the judge, and the judge alone, to determine as a matter of law whether the occasion is privileged, unless the circumstances attending it are in dispute, in which case the facts necessary to raise the question of law should be found by the jury. It is further for the judge to decide whether there is any evidence of express malice fit to be left to the jury — that is, whether there is any evidence on which a reasonable man could find malice. Such malice may be inferred either from the terms of the communication itself, as if the language be unnecessarily strong, or from any facts which show that the defendant in publishing the libel was actuated by spite or some indirect motive. The privilege extends only to a communication upon the subject with respect to which privilege exists, and it does not extend to a communication upon any other extraneous matter which the defendant may have made at the same time.”

Other Questions


In a defamation action, can either party give evidence in proof or disproof of malicious motive in the mind of the publisher of defamatory material? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
Is the material used in the repair of shoes considered a factor in determining the amount of material that enters into the repairs of shoes? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
Can a plea of justification be defended as to the truth of any defamatory statements in a series of articles? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What constitutes a material alteration to a mortgage? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
In what circumstances will a jury consider the materiality of an insurance statement? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What are the implied warranties and conditions in the third class of an engine warranty agreement? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What is the legal test for the interpretation of implied contract? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
Can a court compel a municipality to open a original road allowance and make it fit for being travelled upon as a public highway? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What is the effect of failing to call a material witness? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What is the obligation of a person who is discovered during a medical examination to inform himself on all matters material to the issues? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
X



Alexi white


"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.