What is the test for a material change in custody?

Manitoba, Canada


The following excerpt is from Bloomfield v. Halfyard, 2019 MBQB 81 (CanLII):

What is meant by material change in circumstances and what the court has to consider in a variation which would result in a change of custody has been reviewed in the case of Gordon v. Goertz, 1996 CanLII 191 (SCC), [1996] 2 S.C.R. 27 (at para. 49): 49 The law can be summarized as follows: 1. The parent applying for a change in the custody or access order must meet the threshold requirement of demonstrating a material change in the circumstances affecting the child. 2. If the threshold is met, the judge on the application must embark on a fresh inquiry into what is in the best interests of the child, having regard to all the relevant circumstances relating to the child’s needs and the ability of the respective parents to satisfy them. 3. This inquiry is based on the findings of the judge who made the previous order and evidence of the new circumstances. 4. The inquiry does not begin with a legal presumption in favour of the custodial parent, although the custodial parent’s views are entitled to great respect. 5. Each case turns on its own unique circumstances. The only issue is the best interest of the child in the particular circumstances of the case. 6. The focus is on the best interests of the child, not the interests and rights of the parents. 7. More particularly the judge should consider, inter alia: (a) the existing custody arrangement and relationship between the child and the custodial parent; (b) the existing access arrangement and the relationship between the child and the access parent; (c) the desirability of maximizing contact between the child and both parents; (d) the views of the child; (e) the custodial parent’s reason for moving, only in the exceptional case where it is relevant to that parent’s ability to meet the needs of the child; (f) disruption to the child of a change in custody; (g) disruption to the child consequent on removal from family, schools, and the community he or she has come to know.

Other Questions


Is there a material change in the circumstances of custody of the child since the last custody order has been made? (Alberta, Canada)
What is the test for material change in a custody arrangement? (Ontario, Canada)
Is there a material change in circumstances affecting the child under a custody or access order? (British Columbia, Canada)
What is the test for a parent to request a material change in custody of their child? (Alberta, Canada)
Can a material change in circumstances be considered in a custody application? (Ontario, Canada)
What constitutes a material change in circumstances for a judge to vary a custody order? (British Columbia, Canada)
When will the court consider a material change in circumstances in a custody matter? (British Columbia, Canada)
What is the material change in circumstances relating to custody and access? (Ontario, Canada)
What is a material change in the definition of a change in terms of material change? (Ontario, Canada)
What is a material change in an order and what is the test for material change? (Ontario, Canada)