Is a contractor responsible for damage caused by an independent contractor?

Alberta, Canada


The following excerpt is from Rutherford Condominium Association v. Raicon Industries Ltd, 2002 ABPC 204 (CanLII):

One who commits a wrong or fails in some duty owed to another is liable for the consequences thereof but someone who employs an independent contractor to do work, in itself lawful and not of a nature likely to involve injurious consequences to others, is not responsible for the results of improper or careless performance of that work since although he has ordered the work to be done, he can not control the manner in which it is done by the independent contractor. However, one who orders work likely to be attended with injurious consequences to others, unless steps are taken to prevent such consequences, can be vicariously liable for any damage caused by the independent contractor in doing such work. “...A man who orders a work to be executed, from which, in the natural course of things, injurious consequences to his neighbour must be expected to arise, unless means are adopted by which such consequences may be prevented, is bound to see to the doing of that which is necessary to prevent the mischief, and cannot relieve himself of his responsibility by employing some one else - whether it be the contractor employed to do work from which the danger arises or some independent person - to do what is necessary to prevent the act he has ordered to be done from being wrongful. There is an obvious difference between committing work to a contractor to be executed from which, if properly done, no injurious Consequences can arise and handing over to him work to be done from which mischievous consequences will arise unless preventive measures are adopted.” (Bower v. Peate, (1876) 1Q.B.D. 321,323)

Other Questions


Can a property owned, occupied or used by an independent contractor and in care, custody and control of the same independent contractor be considered a "used by" insured? (Alberta, Canada)
Is a homeowner liable to an employee of an independent contractor who is injured as a result of unsafe procedures used by the contractor? (Alberta, Canada)
What is the legal test for damages for damage caused by a breach of the law by a party to a property? (Alberta, Canada)
Is some damage sufficient for a cause of action to arise and a limitation period to start run? (Alberta, Canada)
Can an expert testify that the disclosure of damage to a vehicle causes the vehicle's value to decline? (Alberta, Canada)
What is the test for determining whether there is no scientifically proven cause or causes of fibromyalgia? (Alberta, Canada)
What is the test for determining whether an occupier of a building is liable for damage caused to a plaintiff's property by an electrical shock? (Alberta, Canada)
In what circumstances can a plaintiff sue a manufacturer or designer of a barbecue for damages caused by a gas leak close to one of the burners? (Alberta, Canada)
In what circumstances will an independent contractor be held liable in a personal injury action for changing a piece of plywood in the middle panel? (Alberta, Canada)
Is there a cause of action for damages arising from the date of time running out? (Alberta, Canada)
X



Alexi white


"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.