What is the test for determining whether an employer is liable for injuries sustained by a plaintiff in a motor vehicle accident?

Saskatchewan, Canada


The following excerpt is from Western Trust Co. v. Willoughby & Duncan, 1914 CanLII 339 (SKDC):

Moore v. Manchester Liners [1910] A.C. 498, 79 L.J.K.B. 1175, was applied and followed in Gonyea v. C.N.R., supra, and need not be further referred to. Two other cases cited on the argument very pertinently support the conclusions I have reached. Dawbarn on Employers’ Liability, 4th ed., p. 112, says:— What is evidence or no evidence is often separated by a line of very fine drawing. Roughly there are two great classes of such cases (a) When the accident takes place on the actual scene of a man’s duty, and (b) when it does not. As a rule, in the former class of case the workman gets a very liberal benefit of the doubt, and very slight evidence is required to warrant the inference of fact that the accident arose out of and in the course of the employment. So much so that the onus of proof seems almost shifted on to the employer to prove the contrary.

In support of this the author cites with other cases, McNicholas v. Dawson [1899] 1 Q.B. 773, 68 L.J.Q.B. 470, where the deceased was found crushed to death on the scene of his duty, by machinery that it was his duty to start. There was no proof as to how the accident occurred, but it may have happened through attempting to leave by a forbidden door. Assuming that it did so happen the plaintiffs were nevertheless found entitled to recover.

Other Questions


What is the test for determining whether a defendant is liable to a plaintiff in a motor vehicle accident for breach of contract? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
How have courts dealt with a claim for damages arising out of a motor vehicle accident under the Motor Vehicle Accident Prevention Act? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What is the test for a plaintiff to prove that he was not responsible for the injury he sustained in a motor vehicle accident? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What is the test for determining whether a plaintiff is a contributory driver in a motor vehicle accident? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
Can a defendant be found not to be negligent in a motor vehicle accident where the vehicle is locked in a fenced-off secure area and the keys to the vehicle are locked? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What is the difference between a plaintiff and plaintiff in a motor vehicle accident claim for medical attention? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What is the test for determining whether a coupling between a vehicle and a crane is a cause of damage to the vehicle? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What is the test for personal injury claims in a motor vehicle accident case? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What is the test for loss of earning capacity for a plaintiff in a motor vehicle accident? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What is the equitable contribution of an insurer to a plaintiff's insurance policy when they are injured in a motor vehicle accident? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
X



Alexi white


"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.