What is the test for a right of action under the statute of 1540 for damages arising from a covenant which does not run with the land?

British Columbia, Canada


The following excerpt is from Vancouver (City) v. Beaufort Properties Ltd., 1982 CanLII 577 (BC SC):

In Re King, supra, Lord Denning discusses the distinction, in this context, between covenants which run, and do not run, with the land (at p. 481). In the class of matters which do not run, but remain with the assignor as “ 'merely a chose in action' sever from the reversion”, Lord Denning places a right of action on a covenant to pay compensation for damage done to the land by a lessee having the right to mine for clay: Martyn v. Williams (1857), 1 H. & N. 817, 156 E.R. 1430. But Lord Denning observes that the right to sue on a covenant to "repair" or "re-instate", in respect of depreciation which had occurred during the assignor's time, that is to say prior to change of ownership, fell into the other class. He explains the distinction (at p. 480) thus: If the covenant to repair or reinstate had been performed, the advantage of it would have accrued to the heir or devisee and not to the executor. It was only right, therefore, that when the covenant was not performed, the heir or devisee should have the damages for nonperformance. It would obviously be wrong that the damages should go into the pockets of those entitled to the personal estate. The loss had not accrued to them, but had been suffered by the heir or devisee of the real estate. I understood counsel to be agreed that Lord Denning in this case correctly states the law under the statute of 1540.

Other Questions


Does a right-of-way easement over a strip of land give a dominant tenement the right to deposit vehicles on the land? (British Columbia, Canada)
Can a plaintiff bring an action for damages for damages arising from unlawful administrative acts? (British Columbia, Canada)
What is the range of damages for damages for breach of a contract where the contract price of a parcel of land was significantly lower than the value of the land at the time the contract was signed? (British Columbia, Canada)
What is the limitation period for an action for damages arising from a circumcision performed on 26th September 1974? (British Columbia, Canada)
What is the test for an application to have a defendant father's claim for damages arising out of his actions as a carer? (British Columbia, Canada)
What is the “essence” of the test for determining whether a claimant had pursued the driver as resolutely and resourcefully as they would have done if the claimant intended to pursue any right of action arising out of the accident? (British Columbia, Canada)
Is a constructive trust an appropriate remedy in an action for damages arising out of a loss of income from a contribution made to a pension scheme? (British Columbia, Canada)
In what circumstances will the Respondent at the Human Rights Tribunal of B.C. claim that the Applicant be denied the right to continue to pursue his human rights claim? (British Columbia, Canada)
What are the respective rights of the parties when an easement holder asserts a right to fence lands owned by a servient property? (British Columbia, Canada)
What is a "legal right" for a plaintiff to sue for damages arising from copyright infringement? (British Columbia, Canada)
X



Alexi white


"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.