Can a union local commence an action for declarations that certain employment agreements and escrow agreements are void?

Ontario, Canada


The following excerpt is from Ottawa Police Association v. Ottawa Police Services Board, 2014 ONSC 1584 (CanLII):

In Ginter v. Gardon, the court considered two actions, “the 1999 action” and “the 2000 action”. Nordheimer J. granted a representation order in the 1999 action permitting a union local to commence an action for declarations that certain employment agreements and escrow agreements were null and void. In that case, the local was a subset of the union and the action did not benefit the entire union. Nordheimer J. denied however, a request for a representation order in the 2000 action where he found that the claim was an “accumulation of personal claims”.

As outlined at paras. 16-20 of the Ginter v. Gardon decision, the refusal to grant the representation order in the 2000 action was based on four factors: 1. The proposed representatives had individual claims in addition to the representative claims and there was a real risk of conflict arising between the two. 2. Three of eleven executive board members did not wish to be parties and there was no evidence that the other members wished to be represented. 3. The claims in certain aspects were individual claims (e.g. loss of reputation, back pay etc.) and the nature the claim raised the concern that it would be unfair to the defendants to be denied the opportunity to examine each of the claimants for discovery. 4. The small number of parties involved meant that there were no appreciable savings of costs or other efficiencies to be achieved.

Other Questions


What is the duty of an employer to seek alternate employment for employees who have lost their employment due to the loss of their employment? (Ontario, Canada)
When a motion judge approved the sale agreement and technology license agreement and approval of the sale and sale agreement, what analysis applied? (Ontario, Canada)
Can a contingency agreement be declared void or unenforceable? (Ontario, Canada)
Is a non-solicitation clause in an employment agreement enforceable if it is limited to clients or clients of the employer? (Ontario, Canada)
Is a unionized unionized employee entitled to arbitration in a dispute arising out of a collective agreement? (Ontario, Canada)
Is an employer permitted to respond to a union grievance by acknowledging that there has been a breach of the collective agreement? (Ontario, Canada)
Is an applicant entitled to compensation for loss of employment due to the employer’s failure to mitigate her loss by making reasonable efforts to obtain suitable employment? (Ontario, Canada)
What are the redacted text messages of a unionized unionized employee and the union’s lawyer? (Ontario, Canada)
Does a union have standing to bring an action against the union? (Ontario, Canada)
When an employer unilaterally changes the essential terms of an employee’s contract of employment and the employee does not agree to the changes, is the employee constructively dismissed? (Ontario, Canada)
X



Alexi white


"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.