What is the test for a marriage to be void ab initio and accordingly a nullity?

Saskatchewan, Canada


The following excerpt is from Polischuck v. Polischuk, 1975 CanLII 847 (SK QB):

Notwithstanding the good sense of the Haultain judgment in Wylie v. Patton, supra, the facts of the instant case and, mostly important, the provisions of the Act under consideration, indicate that the reasoning of Gilham v. Steele, supra, is applicable and should be followed. That is to say, I adopt the view that the clear necessary intendment indicates the conclusion or result arrived at in Gilham v. Steele, namely, the purported marriage to be void ab initio and accordingly a nullity. A very narrow point causes me slight hesitancy. It is the reference in s. 50 (now s. 46) to the non-registration of a marriage "by the officiating clergyman or other person". The "other person" is one authorized by the Act to solemnize marriage. Under s. 44 of the Act (now s. 41), supra, the responsibility to register a marriage conducted in accordance with the rights and ceremonies of the Doukhobortsi, rests with one or both of the parties thereto. Was it then open to either or both of the parties to this marriage to make application for a declaration of validity under s. 50 (now s. 46)? A liberal and broad interpretation of the statute as a whole and s. 50 (now s. 46) in particular favours an affirmative answer to that question. I am sure that I would give such an answer if I were required to do so but what I am about to say, being conclusive of the matter on another, although somewhat related point and leading to the same result makes it unnecessary to dwell further on that question at this time.

Other Questions


What is the meaning of the words “the marriage of the testator” and “made in contemplation of the marriage” in the Marriage of the Testator? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What is the test for an action for a declaration of nullity of marriage on the ground of coercion? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
In a common-law marriage between Indians living on a reserve, can a common law marriage be valid? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
How have the courts dealt with the issue of traditional marriage in the context of maintenance and/or traditional marriage? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What is the test for marriage to be held in a civil marriage? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What is the test for a breach of promise of marriage? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What is the test for determining whether there was connivance between the parties in the context of the definition of a party to a marriage contract? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
Is a conditional gift in restraint of marriage valid? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
How much weight should a factor be accorded to a spouse's ability to control the relationship? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
Is a conditional gift in restraint of marriage void? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
X



Alexi white


"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.