Can a judge proceed cautiously if she conducts a stage two policy analysis under the Anns test on a pre-trial motion?

Ontario, Canada

The following excerpt is from Arora v. Whirlpool Canada LP, 2013 ONCA 657 (CanLII):

As this court commented in Haskett v. Equifax (2003), O.R. (3d) 577, a judge must proceed cautiously if she conducts a stage two policy analysis under the Anns test on a pre-trial motion. Feldman J.A. explained, at para. 24, that while the judge may well recognize potential policy concerns at the second stage, she should be circumspect in using those policy concerns to decide the “plain and obvious” question without a statement of defence and without any evidence. She cautioned, at para. 52: A court should be reluctant to dismiss a claim as disclosing no reasonable cause of action based on policy reasons at the motion stage before there is a record on which a court can analyze the strengths and weaknesses of the policy arguments…. [Citations omitted.]

Other Questions

What is the effect of a motion judge's finding that an insurer's obligation under a life insurance policy does not change adversely after an accident occurs? (Ontario, Canada)
What are the implications of a motion judge's decisions regarding the restoration of an action to the trial list under r.48.11 and the dismissal of an Action for Delay pursuant to r.24.01? (Ontario, Canada)
Can a party who sets down an action for trial proceed with a motion for leave to dismiss the motion because of the ongoing pandemic? (Ontario, Canada)
Can a motion judge interfere with the analysis and conclusion of a judge's assessment of the nature of the expression? (Ontario, Canada)
Is there any reviewable error in a trial judge's causation analysis in a personal injury case? (Ontario, Canada)
What are the consequences of errors in a motion judge’s spousal support analysis? (Ontario, Canada)
What is the standard of review for a motion of appeal against a finding of fact made by the trial judge? (Ontario, Canada)
Is there any case law that supports a motion judge finding that a plaintiff has a genuine issue for trial over an unpaid bonus? (Ontario, Canada)
How much time has been delayed or adjourned a judicial pre-trial hearing? (Ontario, Canada)
Can a motion judge assume that no further evidence will be adduced at trial on any issue, including discoverability? (Ontario, Canada)

There are no other similar questions at this time.