Is a bequest for religious purposes void for uncertainty?

Saskatchewan, Canada


The following excerpt is from Brooks (Estate) (Re), 1969 CanLII 593 (SK QB):

A bequest for religious purposes is prima facie a bequest for charitable purposes and is not void for uncertainty. It must be so treated unless the testator’s intention to the contrary is clearly shown. Vide: In re McClellan’s Will; Robinson v. McClellan (1918) 46 NBR 161.

In Phelps v. Lord (1895) 25 OR 259, a testator devised by his will to certain named persons who were appointed the executors and trustees thereof, the remainder of his estate to be used to further “the cause of our Lord Jesus Christ.” It was herein held that the legacy was not void for indefiniteness.

In Whicker v. Hume (1851) 14 Beav 509, 51 ER 381, a gift to trustees to apply in such manner as they in their uncontrolled authority should think proper “for the benefit, advancement and propagation of learning in every part of the world as far as circumstances will permit” was held a good charitable bequest.

Other Questions


Can an expropriated property be valued on a valuation based on immediate sale for use by the owner of the land for the purpose of building purposes? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
Is a restrictive covenant with respect to race, race, blood, and race void for uncertainty? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
Is it proper to appoint representation to members of a religious society? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What is business disturbance loss for the purposes of determining whether a business has been adversely affected by the expropriated land? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
Is a gift of funds intended to be used for the purpose of ademption or ademption? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What is the purpose and intent of the BBLA? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
Does the term “or other purposes” following the words “for settlement, mining” in the treaty of September 15, 1874, is ejusdem generis? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
Can a union be held liable for failing to accommodate an employee's religious beliefs? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
If a testator gives all his property to his wife for her maintenance and support purposes during her lifetime, is the devise absolute? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What is the purpose of a loss of dependency award under the Fatal Accidents Act? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
X



Alexi white


"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.